Your website had visitors last week. A few of them read your class times, looked at the photos of the kids' class, got as far as the page where they would have had to type a phone number, and closed the tab.
You will never know their names. The ones who book turn into students you can count. The ones who don't turn into nothing at all, and it is the easiest thing in the world to file them under not interested without ever really deciding to.
Neil's book is blunt about where those people go:
"If someone visits your website, you want to maximize the chances of them leaving their contact information, because when they leave, it's very likely they will not return and you will not get a second chance of turning them into a student."
And on the parent who fully intends to look you up again at the weekend:
"they may intend to come back later, but they probably won't."
The belief worth breaking is not that she wasn't interested. It's that she'll be back when she's ready.
Why won't a parent who liked your school come back on her own?
Because nothing in her week reminds her.
She looked you up on a Tuesday night with her phone in one hand and a child's reading book in the other. She was interested. She was also tired, unsure which night would work, and not certain her daughter would even get in the car. So she did the sensible thing and left it for now.
Now nothing happens. There's no next step in her calendar and no message in her thread. Your school stays exactly where it was in her mind, which is nowhere in particular, and the next time martial arts crosses it will be because somebody else's ad put it there.
This is the same wound as the enquiry that never books a trial, one step earlier. That family at least left you a phone number. This one left you nothing, which is why it feels like there is nothing to work with.
You do have something to work with, and it isn't a name.
What is retargeting, in plain words?
Showing ads to people who have already been on your site.
A small piece of code sits on your pages. When somebody lands on one, that visit is added to a list, and your ads can then be pointed at that list instead of at the general public. Google describes its version as "collections of website visitors or app users gathered by snippets of code added to your site or app", and says people land on one within seconds of the page loading.
If you go looking for this in your own account, the name has moved. Neil's book calls it remarketing, which is what everybody called it, and what Google itself called it for years. Google has since renamed it. "Remarketing" is now referred to as "your data", and Google points advertisers to the Audiences page inside the Campaigns menu. Same mechanism, different label, so the word in Neil's book is not the word on your screen.
The part that catches schools out is that the list can't be built backwards. If there's no tracking code on your site today, the families who visited last month are gone, and no amount of budget next year reaches them. The code is the cheap half of this and it's the half that's usually missing.
Neil's instruction in his book is one sentence long:
"Your website should include tracking code such as the Facebook and Google pixel, so that you can remarket to visitors."
How many website visitors do you need before retargeting works?
Google publishes a minimum for this, and it is the number to check before you plan anything around it.
Your list has to hold at least 100 active visitors or users from the last 30 days before Google will show ads to it. That's the stated minimum whether you want those ads on the Display Network, which is the websites and apps that carry Google ads, on the Search Network, which is Google search itself, or on YouTube. Google also says a brand new list can take 48 to 72 hours to fill up, so an empty one on the first morning isn't a broken setup.
Hold that against your own traffic. A list fills only from visits that happen after you make it, so it can never be bigger than whatever is sending people to your site, and no setting in the account changes that.
So retargeting isn't a channel that stands on its own. It is a multiplier on whatever is already bringing families to your page, and when a campaign is running properly there is a steady stream of interested strangers passing through your booking page every week. That is what makes the list worth having. Running it the other way round, hoping a retargeting audience will fill a school with no traffic going into it, is the version that disappoints people.
Which three audiences are worth building?
In this order, because they are not equally warm.
Warmest: reached the booking page and did not book
This is the warmest audience you will ever have. They read the offer, they got to the form, and something stopped them. The two things you can actually answer are a class time that doesn't fit their week and a child who has gone quiet about the whole idea.
Next: visited any page and did not book
Last: already booked or already enrolled
The fix that makes all three possible: we ask owners to give the booking page its own address on the site, separate from the homepage. Google's own worked example builds a list from a rule collecting visitors to a page whose URL ends with a particular page name, and that is the shape of rule all three of these are built from.
That last one is the one owners skip, and then wonder why their own students keep mentioning the ad.
What should the ad say to a family who has already seen your offer?
Say something she hasn't already read.
She has seen your offer. Repeating it tells her nothing she did not know on Tuesday, and the reason she stopped was never that she had failed to understand two weeks free. Answer the thing that actually stopped her.
If she reached the booking page and stopped
If the child is the hesitation
If she never got that far
The rule behind all three: name the obstacle, not the offer. One specific detail she can act on beats any amount of enthusiasm, and a class time is a detail she can hold against her own week.
If you want the longer version of where those words come from, it is the sentence a parent gave you at your desk, not anything written by us.
Is retargeting worth it for a small school?
Set it up, and expect it to be the quiet one.
Neil's own position on this comes from comparing it with the offline way of doing the same job. His book describes software Madscope uses on some campaigns that can send a one-off postcard or email to a website visitor, and then says plainly which way that comparison fell:
"this software also allows us to retarget the page visitor on platforms like Facebook and Instagram or send them an email and we've found that to be cheaper and more effective."
Read what that is a comparison with. It is cheaper and more effective than printing and posting something to the same person. It is not a verdict against ordinary ads, and the audience it draws from exists only because those ads put people on your site in the first place.
What this won't fix
Four things, and they're all on your side of the mat.
A site with nothing to come back to. If your class times are out of date and there is no way to book from the screen, reaching that parent again just sends her back to the same dead end. Fix the page first.
A worn-out offer. If a family has seen your offer twice and done nothing, the ad is not the problem. Neil's view is that offers wear out over time because the competition gets stronger, so what you put in front of a new family is a live question rather than something you settled once.
A booking page that isn't a page. Covered above, and the one that quietly breaks the other two.
Too little traffic. Below that minimum, there's nobody to show the ad to. The answer is more families arriving, not a cleverer audience.
Where we sit in this
We find the families, get them booked and remind them to come. You welcome them, run a great first class, and enrol them.
Retargeting sits inside our half. The families who reach your booking page and stop are people the campaign already found for you, so letting them go is the one bit of waste in the whole chain, and closing it is our job rather than yours. Chasing the family who stopped at the form is the same work as chasing the one who left a number, which is the follow-up that is hardest to do once the last class is off the mat.
What we cannot do is put the code on a website we do not control. If your site is yours, that part is yours, and it is worth doing this week whether or not you ever run a single ad to the list. The list builds quietly from today onwards and it cannot build from last month.
If you want someone else holding all of this, bring your timetable and the number of beginner spaces you can genuinely take this month. If we do not think we can fill them, we will say so on the call.
Do this Monday
Open your own website on your phone and find the booking page. Check two things: is it a separate URL from your homepage, and is there any tracking code on the site at all.
If the answer to either is no, that's Monday's job, and nothing else on this page matters until it's done. A list holds nobody on the day you make it and fills from the visits that come after, so this week's visitors were never added to anything. Next week's do not have to go the same way.
The short version
- A visitor who leaves without booking is not uninterested, and Neil's position is that she probably won't come back on her own.
- Retargeting means showing ads to people who have already been on your site. Google now files it under your data rather than remarketing.
- The list is built by code on your pages and cannot be built backwards, so an untagged site loses every visitor it has ever had.
- Google needs at least 100 active visitors or users in the last 30 days in a list before ads serve to it, which is why we run it alongside a campaign rather than instead of one.
- We build three lists: reached the booking page, visited any page, and already booked. The third one is there to be excluded.
- Say the thing that stopped her, a class time or a nervous child, rather than the offer she has already read.
Questions owners ask
What is retargeting, in plain words?
Showing ads to people who have already visited your website. A small piece of code on your site adds each visitor to a list, and your ads can then be aimed at that list instead of at strangers. Google calls these data segments now rather than remarketing lists, and its own documentation describes them as collections of website visitors gathered by snippets of code added to your site.
Do I need a pixel on my website?
You need some tracking code on the site before any of this is possible, because the list is built by the code and cannot be built backwards. Google's documentation says visitors are added to a segment within seconds of landing on a tagged page. Nothing collects the people who visited last month if nothing was watching last month.
How many website visitors do you need before retargeting works?
On Google's side there is a published floor. A segment needs at least 100 active visitors or users within the last 30 days before ads will serve to it on the Display Network, the Search Network or YouTube. A school site with a trickle of traffic will not clear that on its own, which is why this works best alongside a campaign that is already sending people to you.
Is retargeting worth it for a small school?
It is worth setting up, and it is not a substitute for reaching new families. The list only contains people your other marketing already found, so it can never be bigger than the traffic feeding it. Treat it as a way to stop losing the families you have already paid to reach, not as a way to find more of them.
How long should I keep someone on the list?
Google calls this the membership duration, meaning how long a visitor stays on your list before dropping off it. Its default is 30 days and its maximum is 540, and its own advice is to match that window to how long your ads stay relevant to the person. A parent deciding about a class is not a car buyer. If she has seen your offer for a month and done nothing, the offer is the thing to change, not the window.